[Her uncertainty grows. Even as this man has managed to be unsettling, she can't deny that his words sound convincing. There aren't any obvious lies there. And if he is telling the truth, it means the fae has been tricking her the whole time. She might not have met such beings in her home, but her experience in this world has taught her that they can be tricksters.]

I... I... The two of you are connected, that's for sure. [She tries calling out for the fae.] Oi!! I wanna 'ear your side too! That's the one way we can know for sure wot's for real, yeah?