"Because no one should have to deal with this. You don't look like you deserve it."

Even in her case, though se deserves it. It's a weird circumstance for her, but for Hunter? It certainly doesn't seem like he would have done anything to bring out someone's ire, and certainly not for just existing, which it sounds like is his case.

"And no, I don't know your great aunt. Is she the cause of your whispers? Of your curse? Of what you hate about yourself?"